Friday, October 9, 2009

Why some computers are better than others

Computers come in all different sizes these days. But what makes one computer better for one task that another? The technical answer is bus segments. Think of these like lanes of roads running to each device in your computer.

In a more expensive computer, each device has direct lane access to the processors and ram. This means that each device has direct communication, and therefore can take full advantage of speed.











In order to save costs, manufacturers combine traffic on the same lane. In this example the onboard devices such as USB, Firewire and network share with Slot 1. This means if you have a device in slot 1 that requires a lot of communication with the processors, such as a video card. Then using the onboard ethernet would probably affect the quality of your video on your monitors. This is an extreme example.








This dramatically affects the performance of your system. If you had a video capture card in slot 3, and a drives connected to a card in slot 4, you would have issues getting enough information through the bus, and therefore drop frames, or have unexplained video playback issues. This is not a reliable solution. If you put the video capture card in slot 2, and the drive controller card in slot 3, then they do not cross talk.











Traditionally the more expensive the computer, the more bus segments (or in the example, Lanes). Most manufacturers poorly document the amount of bus segments in their computers. Thus making it more difficult to make a generic white box computer reliable and guaranteed solution. Also, computer manufacturers are always changing and updating to the latest chip and revisions, so one model of computer may vary in bus segments from another, even if they appear to be the same.

Many Video and Audio software companies support specific machines to make the choice easier and the opportunity for success greater. Major manufacturers, like HP and Dell guarantee a specific model will be unchanged. This way once the model is tested and document, it is available for people to purchase.

As computers get faster, and architechture continues to change, eventually everything will have it's own bus segment.

How not to get burned using firewire

Apple introduced Firwire in 1995, and toward the end of the Decade became the interface to have. Firewire, or the technical name IEEE1394 or OHCI, works at 2 different speeds. Firewire 400 was 400mb/second, and Firewire 800 is 800mb/second.

Firewire can transmit video or connect drives for data transfer. Theoretically you can connect 63 firewire devices to a system. However, my practical experience is a maximum of 4 drives on each firewire port.

A video device communicates differently than a drive. We have seen issues when you connect a firewire drive, and a video device to the same card. Both Aja and Avid recommend using an additional firewire cards.



This diagram shows how devices communicate on a Mac Pro. We see that the Firewire 400 and 800 ports on the front and back of the Macintosh connect to the same internal Firewire chip.


In my experience, if you connect a video device to any of these ports on the front or back, and a firewire drive you will have a potential for conflicts. This is displayed as dropped frames, the deck not responding, the capture aborting, or video not being able to control the video device properly.



The best way to work around this is to either add an additional firewire card to the system.

Firewire cards we have had success with:

These are best practices to ensure you have success every time you work with your video equipment.


Sources: Wikipedia


Followers